Wednesday, September 13, 2017

The Identity Balance




John Calvin in his Institutes of the Christian Faith,  wrote:



“Our wisdom . . . consists almost entirely of two parts: the knowledge of God and of ourselves. But as these are connected together by many ties, it is not easy to determine which of the two precedes and gives birth to the other.” 



In other words, we need to know ourselves in order to know God, and we need to know God in order to know ourselves.

It’s easy to see the hang-ups we have from having too low or two high an opinion of ourselves.  If we have a poor sense of our own worth, we may try to overcompensate destructive ways. But if our sense

of identity is too high of self-esteem, we wind up self-centered and inconsiderate of others.

But how does this connect with the knowledge of God.  If our self-identity is too low, then it is difficult to see how God can love us.  But if our self esteem is too high, we can easily forget Him. Either way,  an improper sense of identity can cause us to fall off that tightrope balance that is the “narrow way”  righteousness.  To fall of doesn’t mean death, since we are in God’s hands, but it does make it difficult to know him and have faith in Him. 

Our sense of identity has two parts.  We are aware of ourselves as belonging to a community, giving us  a place in a wider world.   An American sees himself as belonging America, just as a Roman saw himself as belonging to Rome. A Christian equally defines herself being in Christ, which is what the word “Christian” originally meant.

We grow faster in our faith when we live it inside a supportive community.  It also gives us a place to express and communicate our faith with others.  Love calls us to togetherness, while self-love (which is of equal importance to love of others) calls us to be alone.

 We are also self-aware, having a personality that is different from the rest. We are not just American, British, Australian, Catholic, Baptist, or Christian, but we are also individually different.  This self-awareness means we can stand alone without external support from others. We can support others and join the crowd, but we can also choose to go our own way.   

Our faith defines our community and our inner knowledge. We need to be part of a group, but we also need to be away from that group. If we lose ourselves too much in group awareness, we risk becoming blind, overly dependents followers of a cause or cult.  If we lose ourselves in self-awareness, we can become unable to see ourselves properly, and are prone to arrogance.   If we go too far in either direction,  we will not be a whole person. 

Michael Kerr tells the story of a porcupines living in a common burrow while trying to endure a hard winter.  If they huddle closely for warmth, they will get stuck on each others’ quills. If they stay apart, they freeze to death.  We have to live close enough to our fellow people to share their warmth and far enough away to keep from being stuck. [1] Independence keeps us from being led astray, while community spares us from loneliness. 

Dietrich Bonhoeffer famously wrote “Let those who will not be alone fear being in community. Let those who will not be in community fear being alone.”[2]  In order to have a close relationship to God, we need to build bridges to fellow believers, as well as a strong understanding of who we really are.  This is a hard balance to strike, but it is worth the effort. 



Are you more comfortable being alone, or being with others?  We are all think, act and feel differently about what part of this balance of identity is the most important to us.

Think about when you feel closest to God.  Is it when you are worshipping in a crowd or alone in prayer? 

How can you use both your alone time and together time to draw closer to God, who is with us at all times? Write me and let me know what your think.  If this makes you think share it with others, or better yet, take a moment to subscribe to this blog.  Write me a note or a comment. I’d love to hear from you.







[1][1] Quoted in Creating Healthier Churches:  Family Systems Theory, Leadership, and congregational life From the Creative Pastoral Care and Counseling Series, Fortress Press, Minneapolis, Min, 1996, p. 66.
[2] Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Life Together.  

No comments:

Post a Comment